State v. Barlow

After a jury trial, Defendant was convicted of attempted second-degree murder. Before sentencing, the district judge ruled that Defendant qualified for Stand-Your-Ground immunity from prosecution on the attempted second-degree murder charge. The judge vacated the second-degree murder conviction and dismissed that charge. The court of appeals reversed the district court’s immunity order and reinstated Defendant’s attempted second-degree murder conviction, holding that the district judge had no legal basis for his unilateral decision. The State appealed. The Supreme Court reversed, holding (1) the court of appeals lacked jurisdiction to reinstate Defendant’s attempted second-degree murder conviction because the district judge had entered a judgment of acquittal on the charge; and (2) a district judge may sua sponte grant Stand-Your-Ground immunity to a criminal defendant after a jury has returned a guilty verdict but before sentence on the conviction has been pronounced. View "State v. Barlow" on Justia Law